State Matchup: Utah vs. Idaho

Both Idaho and Utah are ideal states to retire in, but which is better?
Both Idaho and Utah are ideal states to retire in, but which is better?
Both Idaho and Utah are ideal states to retire in, but which is better?

Idaho and Utah have a lot more in common than you might think. Both states offer majestic mountain views, abundant open spaces, outdoor recreation, and are great retirement destinations for active adults.

Retirees flock to these states not only because of their varied climates, diverse topographies, and reasonable cost of living, but they also have a great selection of 55-plus communities near prime locations such as Brooke View in Boise, ID or Brio in St. George, UT.

While Utah and Idaho share some similarities, there are a few differences that set them apart that may impact your decision when searching for a 55+ community to call home. Check out how these two states stack up against each other.


Utah and Idaho experience varied climates due to their diverse landscapes. Idaho’s weather varies due to the patterns off of the Pacific Ocean with the northern portion of the state getting more precipitation and colder winters with more snow, while the southern part of Idaho enjoys a warmer climate.

Utah’s climate varies because of its mountainous landscape, which brings dry, semi-arid, and desert climate, and its location in the rain shadow of the Sierra Nevada and Wasatch Mountains, which brings more precipitation. Utah’s weather is also affected by the Pacific Ocean.

A majority of its precipitation comes from the fact that the state is located in the path of Pacific storms from October to May and, during the summer months, the eastern and southern parts of Utah are in the path of monsoon moisture from the Gulf of California.


Both states offer different landscapes. Utah’s topography ranges from deserts and sand dunes to forests and mountain valleys. Idaho is a bit more rugged and is made up of mountains, lakes, and canyons and features major rivers like Snake River, Clark Fork/Pend Oreille River, Clearwater River, and Salmon River. Not to be outdone by Idaho, Utah also offers natural beauty and features canyons, reservoirs, snowy mountains, and the Colorado River winds its way through the state’s terrain. With diverse topographies, Idaho and Utah offer beautiful natural landscapes, wildlife, and plant life.


Idaho is a relatively tax-friendly state that may appeal to retirees. Social Security benefits are not taxed at the state level and the state’s property and sales taxes are low compared to other states. Idaho also taxes other forms of income like retirement income from a 401k or IRA at different tax rates that may range from 1.6% to 7.4%.

Unlike Idaho, Utah does tax Social Security retirement benefits as well as pension income and incomes from other retirement accounts are also subject to the state’s 5% flat income tax. Although the state does collect tax on retirees’ income, they may be able to claim a small credit against those taxes.

Cost of Living

Idaho has a cost of living that is 5% below the national average while Utah’s cost of living is slightly higher, coming in at 3.8% above the national average. Park City, UT is one of the most expensive cities in the state to live in due to its luxurious ski resorts and lavish homes.

Retirees may be able to find more affordable homes in active adult communities in nearby areas, including Garden Park at Daybreak in South Jordan, UT or SunRiver at St. George, UT. Expensive cities in Idaho to live in are Boise and Coeur d’Alene, both of which have a higher than average cost of living. More affordable cities like Idaho Falls or Meridian have a lower than average cost of living.


Both Idaho and Utah offer top-notch hospitals that provide some of the best care and are highly ranked. There are five top-ranked hospitals in Idaho, two of which are known for their high-performing specialties, including Kootenai Medical Center in Coeur d’Alene and St. Luke’s Regional Medical Center in Boise. Utah also has a variety of regionally ranked hospitals throughout the state such as University of Utah Hospitals and Clinics, Intermountain Medical Center, and Dixie Regional Medical Center.


One of the biggest draws to Idaho or Utah are the state’s outdoor recreation and activities. Both states share these qualities, making each an outdoor adventurer’s paradise. Active adults can take advantage of the miles of hiking and biking trails, natural open spaces, rugged mountain terrains, rivers, lakes, and parks.

Idaho is home to numerous state parks and wilderness areas that offer camping, fishing, white water rafting, horseback riding, skiing, and snowboarding in popular areas like Burgdorf Hot Springs, Boise Depot, Clearwater National Forest, and Bonneville Point.

Utah also embraces its beautiful outdoor environment thanks to its Wasatch Mountains and national parks like Bryce Canyon, Canyonlands, Zion, and Capitol Reef. With endless options for outdoor activities, active adults won’t have a problem finding something fun and exciting to do in any season in Idaho or Utah.

Can you spot the $207,744 difference between these identical homes?

Financing is the difference!

Get the details in The 62+ Loan Homebuyers Guide.

55places Mortgage is a joint venture between Mutual of Omaha Mortgage and
Details here.

Share this post:

We're here to help! (800) 928-2055

Call us to speak with a customer service representative.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get Weekly Updates

I agree that 55places and its affiliates, partner providers or agents may call, text, or email me about my inquiry, which may be made with automated means. I understand that my consent is not a prerequisite for buying a property. I may revoke my consent at any time by contacting [email protected] Message/data rates may apply. I also agree to’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

The Best Places to Snowbird in 2021

We’ve gathered 25 of the best places for snowbirds, including cities in Florida, Arizona, California, Texas, South Carolina, and Nevada. For each entry, we’ve also provided a list of recommended 55+ communities in the area. If you’re ready to find your own winter retreat this season, here are some of the best places to consider.

55+ Communities Near Lakes in the Charlotte Area

Dreaming of spending your retirement on the water, boating, fishing, swimming, or just relaxing, soaking up the sun every day? Then, Charlotte, North Carolina should be on your radar.

A happy group of elderly people living in a 55+ community meet the age requirements.

What Are the Age Requirements for a 55+ Community?

For many, the answer to “What are the age requirements for a 55+ community?” may seem obvious. You have to be 55 or older, right? No, that’s not always the case. In fact, there are many scenarios where there’s only one resident who is 55 or older. Also, there are rare cases when no residents is 55 or older. 

55+ Communities Near the Philadelphia International Airport

Active adult homebuyers who seek homes for sale near an airport have options in several Pennsylvania and New Jersey suburbs, but real estate here is in high demand, so availability can be limited. The best advice? If you find something you like, grab it before someone else does!

55+ Communities With Condos for Sale Near Orlando

Condos are a great option for active adults who want to live in or near Orlando, Florida. Some condos are in communities on the water and others include golf courses, private restaurants, and recreation centers. Let’s look at some of the most popular 55+ communities with condos for sale near Orlando.

Is Greenville, South Carolina a Good Place to Retire?

If you’re considering retiring in the Southeast, Greenville in South Carolina should definitely be on your list of places to consider. This mid-sized city has quickly become one of the fastest-growing cities in the South. Here’s everything you need to know if you’re considering retiring in Greenville.

New Jersey 55+ Communities With Easy Commutes to Philadelphia

People travel into Philadelphia for different reasons. Many people work there while others have family who call it home. And there are those who have theater memberships or frequently patronize the restaurants, shops, and cultural attractions on that side of the bridge. For them, living within easy commuting distance to Philadelphia is very beneficial.

About 55places

We’re changing the way people 55 and older are searching for their perfect next place. With a national network of hand-selected real estate experts, plus comprehensive information, unbiased content, and on-the-go insight about thousands of communities across the country, we’re a trusted resource paving the way from here to home. Whether you’re interested in a low-maintenance single-level residence, an active lifestyle or age-qualified community, an intimate enclave, or anything in between, we can help you make your next move the best one yet.

Scroll to Top