Shirley, NY 55+ active adult communities & homes for sale - Page 2

183 homes near Shirley

Sort by:

Relevance

3.7 rating (3 reviews)

Greenwood Village

$100ks

Greenwood Village, Manorville, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1980 - 2000 | 512 homes

Leisure Village

$100ks - $300ks

Leisure Village, Ridge, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1969 - 1986 | 1,500 homes

Leisure Knoll

$200ks - $400ks

Leisure Knoll, Ridge, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1972 - 1982 | 701 homes

Leisure Glen

$300ks - $400ks

Leisure Glen, Ridge, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1985 - 2010 | 646 homes

The Waterways at Moriches

$300ks - $600ks

The Waterways at Moriches, Moriches, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1985 - 1999 | 343 homes

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

4 rating (8 reviews)

Glenwood Village

$100ks - $200ks

Glenwood Village, Riverhead, NY

New and Resale | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1959 - present | 588 homes

The Manors at The Colony ...

$300ks - $400ks

The Manors at The Colony ..., Shirley, NY

New Construction | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2013 - present | 150 homes

5 rating (1 reviews)

Westhampton Pines

$900ks - $1Ms

Westhampton Pines, Westhampton, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2005 - 2013 | 189 homes

3.5 rating (2 reviews)

Foxwood Village

$200ks - $400ks

Foxwood Village, Calverton, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1986 - 2007 | 294 homes

5 rating (1 reviews)

Encore Atlantic Shores

$500ks - $800ks

Encore Atlantic Shores, Eastport, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2004 - 2011 | 240 homes

Download the Ultimate 55+ Homebuying Guide Whether you’re searching for a 55+ community, downsizing, or exploring other housing options, our free-to-download guide will assist you in finding the ideal home for your needs.

1 rating (1 reviews)

Plymouth Estates at Mount...

$400ks - $500ks

Plymouth Estates at Mount..., Mount Sinai, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2006 - 2013 | 285 homes

Windcrest East

$400ks - $500ks

Windcrest East, Calverton, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2004 - 2005 | 126 homes

4.6 rating (9 reviews)

Meadowbrook Pointe Links ...

$300ks - $700ks

Meadowbrook Pointe Links ..., Medford, NY

New and Resale | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2010 - present | 280 homes

Stoneleigh Woods at River...

$500ks

Stoneleigh Woods at River..., Riverhead, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2007 - 2016 | 176 homes

Woodridge Strathmore Terr...

$200ks - $300ks

Woodridge Strathmore Terr..., Mount Sinai, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1974 - 1985 | 226 homes

Saddle Lakes

$400ks - $500ks

Saddle Lakes, Riverhead, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2000 - 2002 | 196 homes

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

5 rating (1 reviews)

Sunken Pond Estates

$400ks

Sunken Pond Estates, Riverhead, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2003 - 2005 | 194 homes

Strathmore Gate East

$300ks

Strathmore Gate East, Coram, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1970 - 1975 | 174 homes

Country Pointe Preserve

$600ks - $900ks

Country Pointe PreserveYaphank, NY

New Construction | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2024 - present | 152 homes

Vineyards at Moriches

$500ks - $600ks

Vineyards at Moriches, Center Moriches, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2008 - 2014 | 92 homes

Country Village Estates

$300ks

Country Village Estates, Coram, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 1993 - 2001 | 195 homes

4 rating (1 reviews)

Vineyards at Blue Point

$500ks - $700ks

Vineyards at Blue Point, Blue Point, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2016 - 2018 | 280 homes

Vineyards at Brookfield

$400ks - $500ks

Vineyards at Brookfield, Center Moriches, NY

New Construction | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2019 - present | 146 homes

The Vineyards at Miller P...

$500ks

The Vineyards at Miller P..., Miller Place, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2004 - 2005 | 85 homes

The Vineyards at Mount Si...

$800ks - $1Ms

The Vineyards at Mount Si..., Mount Sinai, NY

New Construction | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2020 - present | 91 homes

5 rating (1 reviews)

The Villages at Mount Sin...

$600ks

The Villages at Mount Sin..., Mount Sinai, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2005 - 2007 | 185 homes

Eastport Meadows

$400ks

Eastport Meadows, Eastport, NY

Resale Only | 55+ age-restricted | Built 2009 - 2016 | 50 homes

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

Westhampton Pines

30 KIMBERLY DR, SOUTHAMPTON, NY, 11977, Southampton, NY 11977

$1,395,000

2 beds

3 baths

2,400 sq ft

Condo

30 KIMBERLY DR, SOUTHAMPTON, NY, 11977

Community: Westhampton Pines

Westhampton Pines

$1,395,000

2 beds

3 baths

2,400 sq ft

Condo

30 KIMBERLY DR, SOUTHAMPTON, NY, 11977

Community: Westhampton Pines

Greenwood Village

124 VILLAGE CIR 124, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119..., Brookhaven, NY 11949

$179,997

2 beds

2 baths

1,116 sq ft

Condo

124 VILLAGE CIR 124, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: Greenwood Village

Greenwood Village

$179,997

2 beds

2 baths

1,116 sq ft

Condo

124 VILLAGE CIR 124, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: Greenwood Village

Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

55 ROSE LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766, Brookhaven, NY 11766

$548,888

2 beds

2 baths

1,272 sq ft

Condo

55 ROSE LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766

Community: Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

$548,888

2 beds

2 baths

1,272 sq ft

Condo

55 ROSE LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766

Community: Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

Leisure Knoll

257 EDINBURGH DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$539,900

2 beds

2 baths

1,000 sq ft

Condo

257 EDINBURGH DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

Leisure Knoll

$539,900

2 beds

2 baths

1,000 sq ft

Condo

257 EDINBURGH DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

Foxwood Village

1407 MIDDLE RD 45, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11933, Riverhead, NY 11933

$315,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,100 sq ft

House

1407 MIDDLE RD 45, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11933

Community: Foxwood Village

Foxwood Village

$315,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,100 sq ft

House

1407 MIDDLE RD 45, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11933

Community: Foxwood Village

Meadowbrook Pointe Links & Spa

38 AUGUSTA DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11763, Brookhaven, NY 11763

$400,624

2 beds

3 baths

1,440 sq ft

Condo

38 AUGUSTA DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11763

Community: Meadowbrook Pointe Links & Spa

Meadowbrook Pointe Links & Spa

$400,624

2 beds

3 baths

1,440 sq ft

Condo

38 AUGUSTA DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11763

Community: Meadowbrook Pointe Links & Spa

Sunken Pond Estates

3704 AMEN COR, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11901, Riverhead, NY 11901

$529,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,350 sq ft

Condo

3704 AMEN COR, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11901

Community: Sunken Pond Estates

Sunken Pond Estates

$529,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,350 sq ft

Condo

3704 AMEN COR, RIVERHEAD, NY, 11901

Community: Sunken Pond Estates

Leisure Village

395 WOODBRIDGE DR E, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119..., Brookhaven, NY 11961

$322,900

2 beds

1 baths

875 sq ft

Condo

395 WOODBRIDGE DR E, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: Leisure Village

Leisure Village

$322,900

2 beds

1 baths

875 sq ft

Condo

395 WOODBRIDGE DR E, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: Leisure Village

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

240 IRA RD, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766, Brookhaven, NY 11766

$599,999

2 beds

2 baths

1,396 sq ft

Condo

240 IRA RD, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766

Community: Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

$599,999

2 beds

2 baths

1,396 sq ft

Condo

240 IRA RD, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11766

Community: Plymouth Estates at Mount Sinai

Leisure Knoll

473 STRATFORD LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$539,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,350 sq ft

House

473 STRATFORD LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

Leisure Knoll

$539,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,350 sq ft

House

473 STRATFORD LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

The Waterways at Moriches

612 BAY VIEW CIR 12, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119..., Brookhaven, NY 11955

$799,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,874 sq ft

Condo

612 BAY VIEW CIR 12, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: The Waterways at Moriches

The Waterways at Moriches

$799,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,874 sq ft

Condo

612 BAY VIEW CIR 12, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 119...

Community: The Waterways at Moriches

Country Pointe Preserve

128 JUNIPER LN 26, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11980, Brookhaven, NY 11980

$895,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,998 sq ft

Condo

128 JUNIPER LN 26, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11980

Community: Country Pointe Preserve

Country Pointe Preserve

$895,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,998 sq ft

Condo

128 JUNIPER LN 26, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11980

Community: Country Pointe Preserve

Leisure Village

167 VENTRY CT D, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$259,000

1 beds

1 baths

684 sq ft

Condo

167 VENTRY CT D, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Village

Leisure Village

$259,000

1 beds

1 baths

684 sq ft

Condo

167 VENTRY CT D, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Village

Leisure Knoll

330 BROWNFIELD DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$429,000

2 beds

1 baths

1,020 sq ft

Condo

330 BROWNFIELD DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

Leisure Knoll

$429,000

2 beds

1 baths

1,020 sq ft

Condo

330 BROWNFIELD DR, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Knoll

Leisure Glen

7 SAGAPONACK CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$599,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,867 sq ft

Condo

7 SAGAPONACK CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

Leisure Glen

$599,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,867 sq ft

Condo

7 SAGAPONACK CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

The Waterways at Moriches

606 BAY VIEW CIR 6, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 1195..., Brookhaven, NY 11955

$749,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,860 sq ft

Condo

606 BAY VIEW CIR 6, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 1195...

Community: The Waterways at Moriches

The Waterways at Moriches

$749,000

2 beds

3 baths

1,860 sq ft

Condo

606 BAY VIEW CIR 6, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 1195...

Community: The Waterways at Moriches

Leisure Glen

20 WAINSCOTT CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$599,999

2 beds

2 baths

1,666 sq ft

Condo

20 WAINSCOTT CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

Leisure Glen

$599,999

2 beds

2 baths

1,666 sq ft

Condo

20 WAINSCOTT CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

Leisure Glen

9 OAKDALE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961, Brookhaven, NY 11961

$619,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,882 sq ft

House

9 OAKDALE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

Leisure Glen

$619,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,882 sq ft

House

9 OAKDALE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11961

Community: Leisure Glen

Strathmore Gate East

39 FREEMONT LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11727, Brookhaven, NY 11727

$375,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,112 sq ft

Condo

39 FREEMONT LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11727

Community: Strathmore Gate East

Strathmore Gate East

$375,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,112 sq ft

Condo

39 FREEMONT LN, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11727

Community: Strathmore Gate East

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley? 55places can help!

Questions? Call us: (934) 333-5665

The Manors at The Colony Preserve

41 GREENTREE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11967, Brookhaven, NY 11967

$485,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,557 sq ft

Condo

41 GREENTREE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11967

Community: The Manors at The Colony Preserve

The Manors at The Colony Preserve

$485,000

2 beds

2 baths

1,557 sq ft

Condo

41 GREENTREE CT, BROOKHAVEN, NY, 11967

Community: The Manors at The Colony Preserve

1 2 3 4…5

Frequently Asked Questions

What size 55+ communities are there in Shirley?

Of the 1 55+ community in Shirley, it is for sale. By size, there is 1 small community with less than 500 homes.

How many homes are there in the smallest, largest, and average 55+ communities in Shirley?

The smallest 55+ community in Shirley has 150 homes, the largest has 150 homes, and the average community consists of 150 homes.

Are there new 55+ homes available in Shirley?

Yes, there is new 55+ home available in Shirley. The most recent community started in Shirley include The Manors at The Colony Preserve. There is also 1 community in Shirley that offers new construction homes, including The Manors at The Colony Preserve.

Are there gated 55+ communities in Shirley?

Yes, there is gated 55+ community in Shirley. The only 55+ community in Shirley is gated. For instance, The Manors at The Colony Preserve is a gated community with 150 homes.

How long do listings in 55+ communities in Shirley typically stay on the market, and what is the average price of homes for sale?

On average, listings in 55+ community in Shirley stay on the market for around 171 days. The average price of homes for sale in this community is approximately $510,417, though prices can range widely based on the size, location, and amenities of the community. For example, homes in The Manors at The Colony Preserve average around $510,417.

Want more information about active adult communities around Shirley?

Global - Lead Form - Buyer or Renter

First Name

Last Name

Phone/Mobile

Text

I'm looking to:

Rent

Buy

*55places does not provide or maintain community HOA information.

Yes, I want to subscribe to email updates from 55places.com, including newsletters, community announcements, and more.

I agree to receive SMS messages to connect me with a local expert.

By requesting more information, you agree that 55places may call, text, or email you about your inquiry, which may be made with automated means (including recorded voice messages, SMS, or text messages). You understand that your consent is not a prerequisite for buying, selling or renting a property. You may revoke your consent at any time by contacting optout@55places.com. Message/data rates may apply. You also agree to 55places.com’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Want to learn more about 55+ communities in Shirley?

Call us: (934) 333-5665

183 homes

Remove Boundaries ×

Map Satellite

The listings data displayed on this medium comes in part from the Real Estate Information Network Inc. (REIN) and has been authorized by participating listing Broker Members of REIN for display. REIN's listings are based upon Data submitted by its Broker Members, and REIN therefore makes no representation or warranty regarding the accuracy of the Data. All users of REIN's listings database should confirm the accuracy of the listing information directly with the listing agent.
© 2026 REIN. REIN's listings Data and information is protected under federal copyright laws. Federal law prohibits, among other acts, the unauthorized copying or alteration of, or preparation of derivative works from, all or any part of copyrighted materials, including certain compilations of Data and information. COPYRIGHT VIOLATORS MAY BE SUBJECT TO SEVERE FINES AND PENALTIES UNDER FEDERAL LAW.
REIN updates its listings on a daily basis. Data last updated: Oct 13, 2026.
This application does not include information on all of the properties available for sale at this time.

Call Us Call Us

Shirley, NY 55+ active adult communities & homes for sale - Page 2

27 communities near Shirley

183 homes near Shirley

2 beds

3 baths

2,400 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

3 baths

2,400 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,116 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,116 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,272 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,272 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,000 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,000 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,100 sq ft

House

2 beds

2 baths

1,100 sq ft

House

2 beds

3 baths

1,440 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

3 baths

1,440 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

3 baths

1,350 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

3 baths

1,350 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

1 baths

875 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

1 baths

875 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,396 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,396 sq ft

Condo

2 beds

2 baths

1,350 sq ft

House

2 beds