Pelican Preserve vs. The Plantation

Homebuyers looking for Fort Myers homes for sale have plenty of options to choose from.

Active adults who have decided that Fort Myers, Florida is the place to be when they buy their next home will have plenty of options. Fort Myers homes for sale can be found near the beach, on a golf course, and even within a gated community where there are bountiful opportunities for socializing, physical fitness, and learning new things. 

Two of the most popular lifestyle communities in Fort Myers are Pelican Preserve and The Plantation. Both of these communities are well-located and they have single-family homes and attached villas available. Pelican Preserve is for 55+ residents only. The Plantation, on the other hand, does not have any age restrictions. The Plantation is also a bit smaller, with a total of 1,100 homes available as new construction or resale. Pelican Preserve is a master-planned community offering 2,500 homes on a resale basis. 

Which to choose? Let’s take a look at where the similarities and differences can be found.

Pelican Preserve and The Plantation Golf Courses 

Both communities include golf courses. At Pelican Preserve, it’s a 27-hole course and a separate clubhouse for members. The golf clubhouse, which includes more than 24,000 square feet, offers a large pro shop, a modern fitness center, a whirlpool spa, and access to a full dining room, ballroom, and bar. Spoonbills Restaurant can also be found at the Pelican Preserve Golf Club, as well as a day spa. 

Homeowners can buy a golf or a social membership at The Plantation Golf & Country Club. There, residents have access to a championship 18-hole golf course, which was designed by Hurdzan-Fry. There’s also a driving range, a restaurant, and lots of extra outdoor space. 

Homes for Sale in Fort Myers, FL

View of the pond at The Plantation with single-family homes in the background.
The Plantation and Pelican Preserve offer a variety of homes for sale.

Buyers looking for a condo will likely appreciate the homes available at Pelican Preserve. The Chateau Collection has nine condo home models, ranging from 1,229 to 1,450 square feet. Located in a mid-rise building, most floor plans have two bedrooms and two bathrooms. Some also include a den or office. Pelican Preserve also offers carriage homes, which are attached, two-story townhomes. They are available in two models, with 1,710 or 2,376 square feet. Homes have three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and an attached two-car garage. 

For single-family homes and attached villas, either community will have what buyers are looking for. The Plantation has two villa floor plans, six models in their Carriage Home Collection, and over 30 types of single-family homes. Buyers can also select new construction at The Plantation, while Pelican Preserve will only have resale, move-in ready homes.

Community Activities 

View of the clubhouse at Pelican Preserve on a party cloudy day.
Active adults can take advantage of a wide selection of amenities at both communities.

Both communities have an impressive list of clubs, classes, and social activities available to residents. At The Plantation, homeowners can enjoy a book club, fishing club, and travel club. There’s a bible study group, a men’s poker night, and a group that gets together to sew and knit. Zumba and yoga classes are regularly held and there are also group painting classes. There’s a lifestyle director on staff to help with special events and community parties.

At Pelican Preserve, there’s a lifestyle director and amenity managers. Residents are likely to take dance or exercise classes, organize movie nights and nature walks, and join clubs that focus on basketball, pickleball, and painting. 


Each community also has its own long list of amenities. At Pelican Preserve, the Plaza del Sol clubhouse includes a fitness center, steam rooms, sauna, indoor walking track, and indoor pool. There’s an art studio, a hobby shop, a computer room, and a movie theater that seats 100 people. Outside, residents enjoy tennis, swimming pools, a volleyball court, softball field, and a sandy beach. There’s a fishing pier and a 38-acre nature preserve that includes a boardwalk and butterfly garden. 

The Plantation has Somerset Hall and Bridgetown Hall, with each amenity center reflecting the neighborhood in which it’s located. Residents enjoy an activity center with a fitness center, locker rooms, tennis, libraries, and outdoor pools and spas. Bridgetown Hall has basketball courts and Somerset Hall has massage rooms.

Pelican Preserve homes are priced from the high $200s to the high $600s. The Plantation homes are priced from the mid $300s to the mid $900s.

Can you spot the $207,744 difference between these identical homes?

Financing is the difference!

Get the details in The 62+ Loan Homebuyers Guide.

55places Mortgage is a joint venture between Mutual of Omaha Mortgage and
Details here.

Share this post:

We're here to help! (800) 928-2055

Call us to speak with a customer service representative.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get Weekly Updates

I agree that 55places and its affiliates, partner providers or agents may call, text, or email me about my inquiry, which may be made with automated means. I understand that my consent is not a prerequisite for buying a property. I may revoke my consent at any time by contacting [email protected] Message/data rates may apply. I also agree to’s Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

The Best Places to Snowbird in 2021

We’ve gathered 25 of the best places for snowbirds, including cities in Florida, Arizona, California, Texas, South Carolina, and Nevada. For each entry, we’ve also provided a list of recommended 55+ communities in the area. If you’re ready to find your own winter retreat this season, here are some of the best places to consider.

Closed up on a tiny wood home model on green grass with sunlight background.

This Month in Real Estate: A Housing Market Summary

The new year is showing that the predicted changes coming to the housing market were accurate and kept with the trend for 55+ homebuyers. If you’re just entering the housing market as a homebuyer, make sure you’re aware of the changes happening so you’re prepared to make the best purchasing decision. 

Aerial view of a picturesque olive plantation in Bakersfield, California.

The Cheapest Places to Live in California

With almost year-round sunshine, some of the world’s prettiest beaches, world-class shopping and dining, and a never-ending list of recreational and entertainment opportunities, it’s no wonder California is such as sought-after state to settle down in.

A sunset over Huntington Beach Pier in California.

The Active Adult Travel Guide to California

California is known for its diverse regions and cities. This means if you’re an active adult looking to vacation in the Golden State, you’ll have a lot of options. We breakdown the state into its three main regions and find everything you should do while on vacation.

3 Virginia 55+ Communities With Easy Commutes to D.C.

If you’re looking for a 55+ community but you’re still working in Washington D.C., here are several active adult communities that offer easy commutes to D.C. with a chance to take the first step toward retirement.

The Best Washington D.C. Area Communities for Downsizing

Outside of Washington, D.C. in Maryland, active adults can find a number of communities with condominiums and smaller attached homes perfect for downsizing. Here are the five best communities for homebuyers looking to downsize in the Washington, D.C. area.

Annapolis, Maryland: What to Do and Where to Live

Annapolis, Maryland is quaint and historic, with arts, culture, and outdoor activities. Active adults can find varied and affordable homes to buy in age-restricted communities.

About 55places

We’re changing the way people 55 and older are searching for their perfect next place. With a national network of hand-selected real estate experts, plus comprehensive information, unbiased content, and on-the-go insight about thousands of communities across the country, we’re a trusted resource paving the way from here to home. Whether you’re interested in a low-maintenance single-level residence, an active lifestyle or age-qualified community, an intimate enclave, or anything in between, we can help you make your next move the best one yet.

Scroll to Top